Sunday 8 November 2015

Crazy Ladies: Victorian Asylums and Mental Illness

There are certain words, such as asylum and mental illness, which to this day are still publicly misunderstood and remain a taboo subject for the vast majority of people. Nowadays, asylums are well known for being an institution for the care of people who are mentally ill”, but the Victorian asylums which were constructed in vast quantities between the 1800 and 1900, earned a different reputation entirely - a reputation that Victorian novelists thrived on! 



Although the intentions behind the asylums were good, the reality of life in a Victorian asylum was that of one in prison with patients being chained up, held under very strict surveillance and some may say tortured as controversial treatments such as lobotomy were tested on them. As the years passed however, more asylums were built with specific emphasis on patient safety and extensive gardens to allow more freedom and aid their treatments. This significant change in the treatment and care of the mentally ill patients was due to a man named William Tuke, an asylum director, who believed recovery was more feasible if patients were treated more like children than animals. This introduced the idea of running an asylum like a strict household so that sanity would be restored through self-discipline. 
High Royds Asylum, Yorkshire

It is clear that conditions in Victorian asylums improved significantly, but what if some of the patients within the asylum weren't mentally ill at all? 


A scary thought right! Scarier still is the fact that there are many examples of women being incarcerated in asylums when they were of complete sound and mind. In the Victorian patriarchal society, a woman that rebelled against her father or husband was at great risk of being sent to an asylum and declared insane, with no opportunity to contest the allegation. David Wright recognized “the confinement of the insane…as a strategic response of households” (Wright, 137) implying that a troublesome member of a family was often removed to an asylum as an easy option and in some cases to uphold the family’s reputation. The idea of putting a sane woman into an asylum soon entered Victorian novels; an example of which being The Woman in White and in this case the character Laura was admitted to the asylum so her husband could benefit financially. Although the plot is complex, Laura’s husband simply used his influence and “unlimited authority” (Hammerton, 100) to have a perfectly sane woman put away into an asylum with no proof she had an unsettled mind. The Woman in White begins with the sentence “[T]his is the story of what a Woman's patience can endure, and what a Man's resolution can achieve” (Collins, 1) which demonstrates the power of man's influence within society and the mistreatment Laura went through at the hands of her husband. It could also be perceived as Laura enduring the torture of being admitted to an asylum because the treatment she will have been subjected  to and people she will have been surrounded by could have tortured a sane mind.


Model Head for the exhibit at Henry Wellcome's Historical Medical Museum
Victorian literature soon became fixated on the idea of the ‘mad woman in the attic’ and possibly the most famous mad woman character is Bertha, Mr Rochester’s wife in Jane Eyre. The figurine head above, made for the exhibit at Henry Wellcome’s Historical Medical Museum, was supposed to depict the stereotypical ‘mad woman’, but her appearance mirrors Brontë’s description of Bertha from the “quantity of dark, grizzled hair” and the way her eyes “gazed wildly at her visitors” (Brontë, 338). This idea of a mad woman looking dishevelled and wild like an animal made for good literary reading for both contemporary and modern readers, but arguably did not show the majority of women suffering from mental illness accurately - most of them looking the same as you or I! However, Jane Eyre did represent the dangers of keeping the mentally unstable locked away in a domestic sphere, especially when they were characterized by erratic behaviour and could be a danger to themselves or others. This sounds like it should be common sense, but during the Victorian period especially, people were ashamed of mentally unstable family members and tried to hide them away within their households, just like Mr Rochester did in Jane Eyre, or tried to care for them by themselves. People were encouraged to seek help for their ill loved ones and some could say Jane Eyre would have influenced people in their decisions to seek medical aid for those in need. Although within literary works Victorian women suffering from mental illness seemed to become frightening, untamed creatures, the majority of asylums offered a place of safety and humane, respectful treatment which most women admitted to the asylum thrived from.




One example of Victorian literary work which seems to strike a balance between the sane and insane is The Yellow Wallpaper. The narrator is a highly expressive woman, who has a vast imagination but when her husband, who is a doctor, insists she become more passive and less creative she soon becomes obsessed with the yellow wallpaper in her house.  The narrator states 

There are things in that paper which nobody knows but me, or ever will. Behind that outside pattern the dim shapes get clearer every day. It is always the same shape, only very numerous. And it is like a woman stooping down and creeping about behind that pattern(Gilman, p 36). 


This quote is from the middle of the short story and some could read this as the turning point from sanity to insanity as it is clear the narrator has slipped further into her fantasy world. The woman she sees trying to escape from the patterned wallpaper is her imagination's reflection of herself, trying and failing to remove herself from the domestic pattern which is her life. There is an example of a woman who was treated at The Imbeciles Asylum in Caterham who “became obsessed of netting materials, and it was noticed that when occupied with these she was much quieter” and this is also shown in Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper as the narrator's obsession with the wallpaper leads her to appear quieter, passive and more tame in the eyes of her husband, John. This example comes from an article in the magazine Good Words, where William Gilbert visited the asylum in Caterham and witness first hand the woman with her netting materials and the peace it seemed to give her. This review of the asylum and the people within will have shown Victorian readers an alternative view of asylum patients - different to the scary tales literature promoted - that the patients are still people. However, to be controversial, after reading The Yellow Wallpaper one could question what was really going on in the woman's mind when she was looking at the netting? 




The asylums are depicted in  Victorian Literature as dark, scary places filled with animalistic, dangerous creatures which definitely makes for a good, thrilling read for both contemporary and modern readers alike. However, whilst researching the history of these asylums, it becomes clear all was not as it appeared. Husbands admitted wives to asylums to be rid of them, some mentally ill women were locked away in domestic households to avoid embarrassment and others were treated as though they were insane because they had a vast imagination which in this day and age would be celebrated, not condemned. Victorian literature was able to tackle the taboo subject of mental illness and experiment with it in stories, covering every angle of the topic. These Victorian ideas on asylums and mental illness are still recognised today, displaying just how powerful and influential they are.
I mean come on, who hasn't heard a story about a mad woman in the attic?! 



Works Cited

Brontë, Charlotte; Jane Eyre, Penguin Classics, 2006

Collins, Wilkie; The Woman in White, Courier Corporation, 2013

Gilbert, William; Good Words, 1872 (http://www.workhouses.org.uk/MAB-Caterham/)

Gilman, Charlotte; The Yellow Wallpaper, Ohio University Press, 2006

Hammerton, A. James; Cruelty and Companionship: Conflict in the Nineteenth-Century 
Married Life, London: Routledge, 1992

Wright, David; Social History of Medicine: ‘Getting Out of the Asylum: Understanding the Confinement of the Insane in the Nineteenth Century’, Oxford University Press (1997), Volume 28 Issue 4 November 2015


Pictures

High Royds Asylum, Yorkshire:

The Model Head: 
http://www.sciencemuseum.org.uk/broughttolife/objects/display.aspx?id=92685&image=5

The Yellow Wallpaper (Top):                                                                                                    http://withinareverie88.deviantart.com/art/The-Yellow-Wallpaper-204031849

The Yellow wallpaper (Bottom):                                                                      http://larissa.booklikes.com/post/81744/the-yellow-wallpaper-short-story

9 comments:

  1. This was a brilliant analysis of mental institutions and women's oppression during the Victorian age. After only reading a couple paragraphs I started think about The Yellow Wallpaper, being that it is one of my favourite short pieces, it was nice to see that you took the time to discuss it.

    Before reading your post I hadn't thought of how common the motif of women being locked away was with the Victorians, however it is evident that they had quite an interest in the topic. You would think that only women of the time would have written about this topic but it was interesting how you mentioned that Wilkie Collins, a male author, would have a take on it. As I am not familiar with any of his works your post has peaked my interest to study him, particularly The Woman in White, in the future.

    This was a lovely and thought-provoking read! Thank you for it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! I'm so glad you enjoyed it!
      I didn't realise how common it was either till I started researching it and then it seemed to appear so often!
      I love the way you mention the gender of the authors, that would have been another really interesting angle to have approached this topic from!
      Thanks for taking the time to read and comment!!

      Delete
  2. This is so well-considered from all sides of the question! I wonder to what extent doctors at the time considered a 'cure' possible? Maybe mental institutions were reserved solely for those who were considered hopeless cases. In The Woman In White, there were two women who were imprisoned in an asylum, one of whom was actually in some way mentally ill. I wonder if there is an implication that the mentally ill one did in fact belong there, or if she should have been taken care of properly at home or outside the asylum? It seems like mentally or psychologically ill people became something that the Victorians wanted to shove out of sight and not consider, yet another group of people that needed to be 'silenced' for being 'inconvenient'. This would make them a great topic for literature, since this enforced removal from the world suggests that these people had some knowledge or something to say that people in power wanted to conceal.
    Great post, thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a really interesting idea! From what I researched, the idea of a cure when asylums were first constructed wasn't even really considered, the patients were just kept like animals - out of the way, often experimented on. Later on, doctors realised that people could be treated and cures were far more common.
      I think having both women within the story emphasises the difference between the "sane" and "insane" but it would be really interesting to explore what impact of keeping Anne at home rather than in the asylum.
      Thank you for commenting!

      Delete
    2. That's a really interesting idea! From what I researched, the idea of a cure when asylums were first constructed wasn't even really considered, the patients were just kept like animals - out of the way, often experimented on. Later on, doctors realised that people could be treated and cures were far more common.
      I think having both women within the story emphasises the difference between the "sane" and "insane" but it would be really interesting to explore what impact of keeping Anne at home rather than in the asylum.
      Thank you for commenting!

      Delete
  3. Hi Carys,

    I really enjoyed reading your blog and felt a learnt a lot from it. I especially love how you relate the fictional literature to the facts. Even though it may be a fictional character who is considered mentally ill in the novel it is hard to imagine the true horror these people went through in the time period. I further love how you kept it specific to women as it goes into more depth.

    Over all i found this a great read.

    Eliza

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
      It is very hard to imagine the horror that some patients endured, even with my examples there isn't that much detail of an experience within an asylum. Perhaps I should have also looked a a fictional novel that was very specific to an asylum experience!
      Thanks for commenting!

      Delete
  4. Hi Carys,
    I have been always very interested in the field of psychology and I have found your blog entry really fascinating as I really like the way in which you link mental illnesses to literature in the Victorian Period. Moreover, I have read the books you mention and I really enjoyed.
    Well done! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
      Thanks for commenting!

      Delete